Caffe Amici - NY 11784

Caffe Amici in Selden offers a solid full-service Italian dining experience rooted in classic flavors and hearty portions. Located in a modest plaza setting, the atmosphere leans toward comfortable and inviting, making it a practical spot for both family dinners and larger gatherings like rehearsal dinners or birthday parties. The restaurant’s vibe reflects a no-fuss, neighborhood eatery where the focus is on substantial, well-prepared food rather than trendiness.

The menu showcases a range of traditional Italian dishes, with an emphasis on pasta and seafood. Whether you're ordering Lobster Ravioli, Shrimp Scampi, or a slice of their cheese pizza, it’s clear this place puts quantity and quality front and center. Diners frequently find value here, with plates that go beyond just filling but generous enough for leftovers. Classic soups like Italian Wedding and Minestrone also emphasize a home-cooked appeal, particularly fitting for chillier days.

Service at Caffe Amici tends to be attentive, with staff checking in regularly to ensure you have what you need, though occasional lapses in drink refills or timing of dessert prompts have been noticed, especially on busier evenings. If you’re coming on a weekend night, be prepared for a wait of around half an hour, which signals the place’s steady local popularity.

This is a place where you can settle in for a relaxed meal without the pressure of fast turnaround, though some diners have felt slightly rushed when dessert is brought up too soon. The environment fits casual dining well, with a lively yet laid-back energy that suits everyone from couples on a date to groups celebrating an occasion.

Best times to visit: Weeknights or quieter lunch hours for a more relaxed pace; weekend evenings when the atmosphere is lively but expect a wait.

Who will enjoy it most: Those looking for classic Italian comfort food served in hearty portions and people organizing casual group events where accommodating plentiful servings is key.